Collation News II

The new issue of the Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research arrived today. It contains a review by Jacob Lauinger of the revised edition of Cuneiform in Canaan. Lauinger calls the book "an indispensable resoure for scholars interested in the topic" which is high praise. Nevertheless, he complains that several collations that reviewers made in their reviews of the first edition are not incorporated, or only partially incorporated without comment, in the second edition. And he provides further corrections from his own collations based on the photographs or hand copies provided. This is, of course, standard practice in scholarship. If this were American history, however, I am sure that the editors would have been scandalized that he would dare do such a thing. After all, when the historians have spoken the thinking has been done.

The Interconnected Ancient World VIII: Egyptian and Indian Monkeys in Minoan Greece

Another news story of far-flung contact from Greece has appeared. This time it is from Minoan times (slightly earlier than the Mycenaean times we noted earlier). The place is Akrotiti on Santorini (Thera). A mural depicts a number of monkeys, which are not native to Greece. Most of monkeys are baboons from Egypt, but one of them is a langur from India.

We could sit comfortably in our disciplinary silos if the ancients had not monkeyed around with our evidence.

Ad Verecundiam Irony

The ad verecundiam fallacy is the appeal to authority. When an position is brought forth and the position is said to be correct simply because an authority has stated it without regard to evidence or analysis, then it is a logical fallacy.

A variation on this logical fallacy is saying that because an individual is not an authority, they have no right to talk about a subject regardless of their evidence and arguments. This tactic is used to dismiss individuals without considering their argument or evidence.

I have recently come across two instances of this logical fallacy that were rather amusing. Both of them took the following form:

Person A took Person B to task because of something that Person B published dealing with Subject X. Person C took umbrage because Person A is not considered an expert on Subject X and Person C knows of no training that Person A has in Subject X. What Person C ironically ignored is that Person B is not an expert on Subject X and has no training in Subject X either.

What this usually means is that Person C agrees with the position of Person B and not with the position of Person A. Arguments and evidence is irrelevant, as in this case are training and qualifications of the authority (because both lack expertise). The ad verecundiam fallacy is merely invoked as a way of dismissing an argument without considering it. But it remains a logical fallacy. Its use in such circumstances is amusingly ironic.

The Interconnected Ancient World VII: Hathor in Mycenaean Greece

This week archaeologists at the University of Cincinnati announced the discovery of a tholos tomb in Pylos, in Greece. Pylos is located in the southwest corner of the Peloponnese:



A tholos is a circular building with a vaulted or conical roof. Tholos tombs are sometimes called beehive tombs. They are a Late Bronze Age phenomenon. They seem to have first been used in Messenia (southwest Peloponnese) and about 1500 spread throughout Mycenaean territory. The tomb is tentatively dated to about 1500 BC.

This tomb is unusual for a couple of features. First the floor of the tomb was lined with sheets of gold. The second is that "archaeologists also found beads made of amber, carnelian and malachite, and a golden pendant depicting the head of the Egyptian goddess Hathor."

This import of an Egyptian goddess is somewhat surprising because of its early date, but it would not be so unusual. Two First Intermediate Period scarabs and an early Twelfth Dynasty scarab were found in a Middle Minoan IA context from Tholos B at Platanos in Crete (William A. Ward, "The Scarabs from Tholos B at Platanos"American Journal of Archaeology 85/1 (1981): 70-73).



The scarabs date about five hundred years earlier than the Pylos tholos tomb. We also have Aegean goods in Egypt at this time, both in the Middle Kingdom Tod Treasure and in Minoan style murals found in the Second Intermediate Period palace at Tell ed-Daba.

During both the Ptolemaic Period and the Roman Empire trade between Greece and Egypt was routine. We tend to forget that it was taking place much earlier than that. It is nice to have one more bit of documentation.