Wednesday, January 29, 2025

Different Levels of Scholarship

Looking up a rather obscure point in biblical scholarship, I was struck by the differences between scholars on how they dealt with the problem:

The non-scholar ignores the problem.

The theologian makes up an answer.

The third-rate scholar looks up the answer in an encyclopedia.

The second-rate scholar can explain the consensus.

The first-rate scholar can explain why the consensus is wrong.